In the Hands of the Prophets at Memory Alpha
A strange be-robed Bajoran lady is totally pushing her Bajoran religious claptrap in Keiko O’Brien’s classroom and Keiko is not having it. Is this the new Kai? Because if she is, she is terrible. Also she looks more like a person in makeup than any Bajoran so far - come on, makeup department! This is why Babylon 5 won your Emmy in ‘93.
Elsewhere on the station, Miles is working with his new Bajoran assistant who apparently knows her business. She is his prize pupil! But his security tool is missing, so he can’t show her how to use it.
Keiko’s taken her beef with the Bajoran church all the way to Siskotown. Turns out this lady, Vedek Winn, is not the Kai, but she wants to be. She doesn’t have a lot of support on Bajor, but Kira’s in her camp. It doesn’t seem characteristically Kiratastic to have her come down on the side of orthodoxy, but I guess that is the role she is playing this episode.
I don’t remember there being a big kerfluffle about creationism in schools in the early 90s, but the Prophets vs. verteron particles debate is a transparent allegory. Sisko just wants everybody to get along, but the Bajoran is dropping thinly-veiled threats about what might happen if Keiko doesn’t stop teaching wormhole science instead of Bajoran Prophetic Celestial Templeism.
Meanwhile, Miles and his assistant have found his missing security tool all melted up in a plasma conduit with a little bit of the previously-missing Ensign Aquino mixed up inside. A tragic mystery! While he’s telling his wife about it, a Bajoran refuses to sell him a candy stick - a grave insult! - because Miles’ lady wife won’t capitulate to Vedek Winn’s demands. Good thing Odo was around, or that vendor might have gotten a surprise visit from Knuckles O’Brien who, after Captive Pursuit, has developed a taste for alien chins. Dabo!
The Kai wanna-be is throwing down about her religion to Mrs. O’Brien’s students right out on the promenade. Why the other races’ children even give enough of a rat’s ass to be at this little throwdown is uncertain, but I guess it’ll save us having to see a scene later where the five non-Bajoran kids show up to a mostly-empty classroom. The Kai stomps off with all the Bajoran kids, which leaves Keiko only a handful of students.
In the interest of full disclosure, I should note that I am right there on the same side as Mrs. O’Brien, who feels that religion has no place in the classroom. This kind of religion-encroaching-on-secular-institutions thing happens in the US pretty regularly. Every year, it seems, some group or other throws up the smokescreen of “Intelligent Design” “theory” to try to sneak religious beliefs into the classroom.
Sisko has a little father-son chat with Jake and sets a conciliatory tone, namely that just because Jake doesn’t believe a thing doesn’t make it dumb (which I agree with), and that in this specific case, it isn’t that ridiculous to interpret aliens who can see all points in time simultaneously as prophets. He also says that just because you disagree with something doesn’t make it wrong, which I agree with… somewhat less.
On the face of it, it’s true - we can’t make something not be so simply by saying it isn’t. But we also cannot make something so just by saying that it is (although when Captain Picard tells us to make it so, we are at least obligated to try), and when you have observable, verifiable facts and data on one side and unsubstantiated superstition on the other, it would be silly to teach the latter in a science lesson.
Sisko and the writers are giving us Star Trek’s can’t-we-all-just-get-along, wouldn’t-it-be-nice-if-everyone-was-nice take on the debate, which I would be right behind if this were about nothing more than peaceful coexistence in a community or about freedom of conscience.
But it isn’t a matter of whether people should be allowed to believe what they wish. Believe up is down, for all I care. Believe the sky is green, it doesn’t affect me at all. Believe a talking snake got a dude in so much trouble with a god that he had to go father a fiercely inbred family in a desert, you’re welcome to it. This is about what to teach in what amounts to a public school - it’s not really pushing your worldview on someone if that “worldview” is literally a view of the world. If the Bajorans get to have their religious beliefs inserted into the curriculum as an alternative to science, why don’t the Klingons or Ferengi get to object to what is being taught as ethics? Why don’t the Cardassians get a say in what is being taught in a Bajoran history lesson?
After dispensing his fatherly lesson to poor older-than-his-classmates Jake, Sisko goes down to speak to a Bajoran spiritual leader, Vedek Bareil, to try find a way to work out the problems at the station. Bareil, who looks a little like Liam Neeson, seems to sympathize, but he will not help.
Back at Ops, Sisko runs up against a Bajoran plague of not wanting to go to work. He also runs up against DNA evidence that the missing ensign who got all melty in the plasma conduit was actually killed by a phaser. How that shows up in an analysis of Ensign Aquino’s DNA is unclear, but Dr. Bashir has FUTURE SPACE TECHNOLOGY at his disposal, so we’ll just go with him on this.
Miles has problems of his own - namely the concern that his assistant might be a little flower units for our dear chief! Get in line, sister!
And his day only gets worse - while he is discussing some new evidence in the slagged ensign’s murder investigation with Odo, the school blows up! Luckily, nobody was there, but, following an inspiring speech by Sisko, Miles’ apprentice and Vedek Winn share an ominous glance.
She continues looking suspicious while Miles explains the current murder plot theory to Miles. While she’s doing that, a message from Vedek Bareil comes in - looks like he’ll be coming to the station just in time to probably get murdered!
I mean, that’s how it sounds, anyway, from the little chitty-chat about sacrifice (and the possibility of getting executed) that the Bajoran Apprentice has with Vedek Winn immediately after Bareil’s message. But her tracks were not covered well enough - Miles finds a suspicious file in the computer and hacks into it with Dax. It’s an escape route! The computer can’t find anything super unusual at the escape route’s start, but Miles goes to investigate anyway since it found some sort of subspace phlebotinum.
And what does he find out about this phlebotinum? It’s integrated into the weapon-detecting technobabble thingy he and his assistant fixed just the other day, when he discovered his missing security tool thing! SUSPENSE! He warns Sisko, who spots the assistant moving through the crowd right before everything gets all slow-motion-y. Mood-building or spacetime anomaly? They never say. She sloooowly pulls a gun and sloooowly tries to assassinate Vedek Bareil.
Sisko foils the plot with the most graceless tackle I’ve ever seen on Star Trek, which is saying something.
- Keiko faking suspicion of infidelity just to screw with her husband is one of the things that makes her rad
- Jake is easily 5 years older than any of the other kids in his class
- Miles O’Brien does not misplace his tools
- I’m going to call this type of O’Brien-intensive episde a “high-Milesage” episode, and this is my blog so nobody can stop me.
- Favorite exchange of the episode:
Miles: What was he doing in a runabout at four in the morning?
Odo: Apparently, he was getting murdered.
- Those spiritual types love those Dabo girls.